Analyzing Mean Reversion: Part 2 - Testing Through Financial Crises
Summary: In this episode, we continue to delve into the concept of mean reversion during, and its application in investment models. This is part 2 of our mean reversion education series, where we explore mean reversion’s potential to generate positive returns even during the most challenging market conditions.
Mean Reversion During Adverse Market Conditions
Detailed Synopsis: In this episode, we analyze the performance of the educational mean reversion model over challenging market periods: the 2008 financial crisis and the dot-com bubble. We also extend the analysis to cover 30 years of historical data on the S&P 500, specifically analyzing multiple financial crises:
- The 2008 Financial Crisis: This crisis was triggered by the bursting of the United States housing bubble, which had been fueled by the proliferation of subprime mortgages and the securitization of these risky loans. As housing prices plummeted, financial institutions faced significant losses on mortgage-backed securities, leading to a crisis of confidence in the global banking system. This crisis had a profound impact on the market, causing widespread panic, a sharp decline in stock prices, the collapse of major financial institutions, and a severe global recession that resulted in job losses and economic turmoil for years to come.
- The Dot-com Bubble: During the dot-com bubble, which occurred in the late 1990s and early 2000s, there was a speculative frenzy in the stock market, particularly in technology and internet-related companies. Investors poured money into these companies, often without regard to their fundamentals, leading to soaring stock prices. However, many of these companies had little or no profit, and when the bubble burst in 2000, there was a sharp and widespread market crash as stock prices plummeted, causing significant losses for investors and the collapse of many internet startups. The impact of the dot-com bubble was a significant market downturn, erasing trillions of dollars in market value, and it also led to increased regulatory scrutiny and a more cautious approach to investing in technology companies.
- 30 Years of Historical Data: To further validate the concept, we extended the backtesting to cover 30 years of historical data. This includes all crises and downturns, including the Covid crash and the turn of the market due to inflation and interest rates. Over this period, the mean reversion model outperformed the S&P 500, achieving a multiple of its returns. This long-term analysis reinforces the potential of mean reversion as a powerful investment strategy.
Can Mean Reversion Out-Perform the Market?
Mean Reversion is a concept that suggests that phenomena exist in the market that may cause certain assets to have a tendency to revert to their average value over time. It implies that if an asset’s price diverges significantly from its average, it can become likely to reverse direction and return to its mean. While there are various ways to measure mean reversion, we will focus on a simple yet powerful approach for educational purposes that is based on time.
The episode begins by setting the context for the discussion, stating that the time period being analyzed is from April 1st, 2000 to April 1st, 2003 (the .com bubble). This period is significant because it encompasses one of the worst financial conditions in recent history, with the market experiencing a maximum drawdown of over 50%. The podcast highlights that if an investor had followed a buy and hold strategy during this time, they would have experienced losses of over 50%.
In contrast, the mean reversion model used in the podcast generated positive returns of 53% during the same time period. This out-performance is attributed to the model’s ability to identify opportunities to buy assets at low prices and sell them at higher prices as they revert back to their mean levels. The model’s success is further supported by a high probability of profit for each transaction, with a percentage near 70%.
To further validate the effectiveness of mean reversion, the episode extends the analysis to a longer time period of 30 years, from 1993 to 2023. The podcast acknowledges that this is the maximum amount of historical data available within the platform used for the analysis. The results show that the mean reversion model outperforms the buy and hold strategy, achieving a multiple of the return of the S&P 500, while also only trading when the market is going down.
The episode concludes by emphasizing that mean reversion is a concept used in multiple models offered by Quantca Financial, although in a more sophisticated manner. It highlights the power of mean reversion in investment models.
In summary, the episode provides evidence to support the claim that mean reversion does have the potential to outperform the market during periods of market downturns. The analysis demonstrates the potential benefits of using mean reversion as an investment strategy, particularly in managing investments during turbulent market conditions. However, it is important to note that the episode presents a mean reversion model for educational purposes only.
Source Code:
Why Quantca?
Diversify your portfolio with our algorithm-based advisory. Instead of riding entire portfolios through extended volatile market conditions, we use complex mathematics to determine when to be in the market by calculating if the market is going up, down, or if it is likely to change direction. This creates the potential for uncorrelated returns in a variety of market conditions.
We charge no up-front fees, and the client maintains liquidity and control of moving their funds directly through the broker. We offer a variety of models that span from complex equities growth strategies to compounding interest on more-stable short-term debt. Sign up to select one of our services!